definition

Dear White Folks,

April 16th, 2006

Please stop being racist.

Just stop.

I know you think my skin’s just dark enough to look like I tan well, but I’m not white, and I don’t think it’s hard to figure that out. My name, for one, should be a fucking clue. Do you people honestly think that just because my skin’s not too brown for you that means I’ll happily eat up your racist bullshit? Because that’s how it seems to be. Hell knows I have no real idea what’s going on in your heads, because ya’ll seem to be stupid, even those of you who should know better.

I’m not from Mexico. I was born in Utah. I don’t speak Spanish. My grandfather was from Guatemala, that country in Central America that apparently doesn’t exist, because everything south of Texas is fucking Mexico to you.

But my name is a Spanish one. My hair and skin are brown. I have the short stature and figure of a Latin American mestizo, because that’s what I am and where I come from. I’m not tall and thin like an anglo girl; I have the short, thick bones and wide hips of the Mayan women my grandfather came from on one side, the other being the European, yes, European despite their language, conquistadores who gave me my name.

And, despite being raised in the white Mormon cultural vacuum that is Utah, I’m aware of it. You want to know why?

You are the people who can’t remember my last name, unable to spell it correctly even when I tell you how to your damn face, substituting my surname for whatever generic Spanish name comes to mind at the time.

You are the people who put me in the lowest academic classes when I transferred to school in Colorado, apparently assuming from my name that I was one of the many ESL students without even bothering to look at my fucking transcript, because if you had you would have seen that I was supposed to be in the advanced classes. And then you did it to my little sister when she went to middle school, too — making the same mistake two years in a row, which took a total of months of everyone’s life to resolve, again and again and again.

You are the people who assume I don’t speak English, or that I’m uneducated or incapable of being educated, that I’m less than human and unworthy of respect because my last name didn’t come from English or German or whatever other European languages seem more acceptable to you. And if I’m not subhuman I’m a demographic, oh, glee.

And you know what?

You may think that you’re only talking about undocumented Mexican workers when you say racist shit to my face, but you’re the same people who think that we’re all one homogenous group. Hell, you could at least pretend to be concerned about illegal immigration in general, since Mexico isn’t the only place that people come from — so when you only talk about “those people” with brown skin from further South than makes you comfortable, it’s pretty obvious you don’t actually care about the immigration issue. It’s just an excuse, because you’re fucking racist.

When you talk about those “Hispanics” taking all the jobs, it’s pretty fucking obvious this isn’t about immigration — it’s about language and culture and surnames and that which allows you to identify them without knowing anything more, skin. It’s about skin. Because you assume that an entire continent and a half is all Mexico, all immigrants, all illegal. Even those of us who are born here, even those who have lived here for generations longer than your families.

So when you say all these things, it seems pretty clear to me…that you’re talking about me, and forgive me if I find that pretty fucking offensive. Forgive me if that makes me defensive.

When you say that Mexicans are subhuman (and, literally, some of you have actually said this to my fucking face), you’re hurting me. When you talk about how “those people” are taking over and “ruining” “your” country, you’re hurting me. When you say that illegal immigrants deserve no legal rights or protections whatsoever, by extension, you include anyone Latino, you include anyone with a Spanish last name, even those of us here legally, even those of us born here, even those of us with skin pale enough to please you — because you don’t know us. You don’t know who we are, or how or why we’re here, and you all use rudimentary and, frankly, stupid measures to identify us.

So what reaction do you think you’re going to get from me? Why does it surprise you when my feelings are hurt and when it makes me angry? I’m not from Mexico and I’m a US citizen and I don’t speak Spanish — but I’m still going to be fucking personally offended when you say that shit, because people see my name and they automatically lump me into those categories. All. The. Damn. Time. I don’t care if you don’t realize it. I don’t care if you don’t think that about me, personally. I don’t care if I’m white enough that it doesn’t register in your egocentric anglo mind that my feelings as a mutt are going to be hurt. I don’t care, I don’t care, I don’t care.

This is still who I am, and I’m acutely aware of it. It’s your privilege not to have to think. It’s your privilege to plead ignorance, or to claim that’s not what you meant, or that you’re not including me because I’m somehow special and worthy of being elevated to “human” status.

America is a nation of mutts and immigrants and their children. You white people don’t get off talking about how those immigrants are ruining “your” country, because it wasn’t “yours” until you took it, and I think the ruining thing was pretty much all your fault to begin with. (And I’ve got colonial invaders from all over the world in my past, Spanish America, British India and Africa, and who knows where else — but I kind of accept that my ancestors were responsible for that and that I benefit from it.) Your families all came here from somewhere else, and apparently that’s all fine and dandy for you because your names aren’t Spanish and you don’t have indigenous Latin American blood to darken your skin. Why is it different for us? Why don’t we get the benefit of the doubt in the land of opportunity?

I’m not a good little queer, who shuts up and doesn’t trouble you with my existence. I’m not a complacent little bitch who puts up and puts out and takes being treated as anything less than a man would be. I’m not a baby-making machine or a sex object, and I’m not a heterosexual man’s pornographic bisexual fantasy. Given that, I’m not going to be a nice little mestizo, a quiet little mutt, a properly hidden and assimilated Latina to make myself palatable to you, either.

Love, Julie

PS: And you know what else?

My grandmother on the other side was a Mexican immigrant who never became a US citizen. And. She was Anglo. She was from Utah Mormons, from English nobility and German ancestry, totally, completely, thoroughly white. You see, in order for Utah to become a state they had to outlaw polygamy, so my great-great-grandfather and his three or four wives packed up and moved to a Mormon colony in Chihuahua where it was still against the law but no one cared, and they stayed there for generations until they ran out of nice anglo boys to marry their daughters off to.

I’ll bet that blows your narrow little mind. This is what happens when you define a whole country, a whole continent, a plethora of cultures and languages and racial backgrounds, as one homogenous being.

This is what happens: things don’t fit. Reality doesn’t conform to expectation.

Do you like irony as much as I do?

8 Responses to “Dear White Folks,”

  1. Alas, a blog » Blog Archive » Link Farm and Open Thread #19 Says:

    [...] Definition: Dear White Folks When you talk about those “Hispanics” taking all the jobs, it’s pretty fucking obvious this isn’t about immigration — it’s about language and culture and surnames and that which allows you to identify them without knowing anything more, skin. It’s about skin. Because you assume that an entire continent and a half is all Mexico, all immigrants, all illegal. Even those of us who are born here, even those who have lived here for generations longer than your families. [...]

  2. Maria Says:

    I got here from Alas, and I just wanted to say that I totally feel you here. I’m a Cuban American mestiza and people can never seem to decide if I’m a sub-human lating worthless immigrent or just white enough that I should agree with them about all of those sub-human lating worthless immigrents. Either way it makes me furious, but I’ve never been able to but how it makes me feel into words (all I can generaly manage is incoherent sputtering:-)) So thank you for doing so.

    Maria

  3. Maria Says:

    wow, sorry about the spelling. I should really learn how to proof read.

    Maria

  4. Sarah Says:

    As a white woman I would really appreciate if you could tell me whether something is racist or not.I noticed you found it was racist that people assumed that you spoke Spanish. This reminds me of a situation I have at work. I process the medical billing for a workers comp law firm. When someone gets hurt, I or one of two other workmates calls them or their lawyer up to get thier side of the story. Only one of us speaks Spanish, so when someone has a Spanish sounding last name, we usually have her call, just in case the person has trouble with English. Is this racist? Everyone in the office is white (which makes me feel uncomfortable but is out of my control) so we have no way of knowing. I have come to realize I can’t always trust my internal racism barometer on these things, since I’m white. Thank you.

  5. earlbecke Says:

    Hmm, interesting question, Sarah. I don’t necessarily think it’s racist to assume I might speak Spanish, because I understand why that assumption is made and I do think it’s important that your office tries to accomodate the needs of non-English speaking people. I think it’s very important for companies to try to hire bilingual staff in areas with lots of Spanish-speaking people, like where I live.

    As for whether the assumption is racist or not…I think it depends on the situation. I don’t fault anyone for thinking I might not speak English if they’re coming from a place where they’re genuinely trying to be helpful. (My sister really does, but that’s her issue. :) It’s a practical assumption to make in many situations and I think it does more good than harm. So, in the case of your office, I don’t think it’s racist. I think you’re trying to work with people in a way that makes them comfortable (or, indeed, that makes it possible for you to work together at all).

    It’s more when it’s a negative thing that it bothers me…when people assume I have to be a certain way because of some stereotype they’ve set up in their head. If that makes sense. I know people who will generalize as if everyone with a Hispanic name is an undocumented worker who doesn’t care about making an effort to learn English–which is clearly false, since there are plenty of people whose families have lived here for generations. It’s more when the assumption is made in conjunction with other, overtly racist attitudes that I find it offensive. On its own, it’s not racist, and I understand it’s often a practical consideration, but the context in which I find it is what can make it seem racist to me.

    Does that help clarify? :) I’m a pretty tired right now so just ask for clarification if I’m not too coherent.

  6. Leila Says:

    I stumbled on your blog, and I have to say, I FEEL FOR YOU! I am half Persian (Iranian). Some people notice I look different, others think I am just another white American. Some people try to speak Spanish to me, and though I know a good bit of Spanish, it’s not my heritage. Most people don’t guess that I have the enemy’s blood flowing through my veins. Though my name is obviously not an American name, they carry on as if I am one of them. I hear their racism, their hatred for all things sub-American, and I am disgusted. Right in front of me, people have shouted that we should just nuke Iran, kill those evil A-rabs, wipe ‘em off the map and be done with it. What can you say to someone who is so irrational? Should I start with, Guess what, Iranians are white? Yes, Aryan, not Arab. We might look a little different, but I check “Caucasian” on my FAFSA, just like you! And I’m not Muslim, but if I was, I wouldn’t automatically be a terrorist! People are just so uneducated, so quick to stereotype. I am very aware of mainstream America’s viewpoints on Islam and immigration. The general public buys into any theories that feed their superiority complex. Ironically, a certain segment of society claims that we are doing the right thing in Iraq because we are saving the Iraqi people from a miserable life under a ruthless dictator. But, don’t let those people escape to America. They call me an isolationist for opposing invasion, yet they want to build a freaking fence across the ENTIRE southern border of the United States to stop those dirt-poor “Mexicans” from getting into the country and building a better life. Start a war to free these people, but don’t let any undesirable immigrants in! The Great American Hypocrisy.

  7. Christiene Says:

    I pretty much agree with most of your thoughts about racism and I totally feel for you. Sometimes, people stereotype other people and it does hurt a little. I blame the media a little for this. Sometimes, those perceptions are taken from what people see on TV or anywhere else (the internet, for example)

    And it is a good thing you were able to share your experiences with us. :)

  8. Scott Says:

    At first I was offended that you directed your rants towards “white folks” because that is racial stereotyping as well. But then I realized you live in Utah. I should expect that in some place like that I suppose where most people are white and not very experienced with other races. You should move to some place that is more diverse like Houston or New York City where there is a bigger mix of races. The white people I hang out with are much more tolerant of other races (and need to be since whites are a minority here). Of course, I get the opposite where Hispanic women (usually immigrants) assume that us “white folks” are all rich and that there are no poor white people. Give me a break. Not all white people are the same! I really hate being stereotyped by Hispanics and Blacks as being racialist or prejudice or wealthy just because I am white. Especially since I am none of those. So I feel your pain about being stereotyped. Hispanics stereotyping me as a typical “white” pisses me off too. So I can understand how you get pissed when the opposite happens to you.

    Much love. And smile. :)

Leave a Reply